A note from Martha: My son Christian put this guide together after spending way too much time on Reddit's first-time buyer forums. I've been selling homes in Greenwich for over 40 years, and I can tell you that every single question in here is one I've heard from real buyers sitting across my desk. Christian wrote it the way he talks, which is not the way I'd write it, but that's exactly why it works. If you're a first-time buyer feeling overwhelmed, this is for you.

---

The 20 Questions Every First-Time Buyer Asks (But Feels Dumb Asking)

Real answers from real estate professionals. No jargon, no fluff.

After reading thousands of first-time buyer questions on Reddit and working alongside my mother in Greenwich and Fairfield County real estate, I've noticed something: everyone asks the same 20 questions.

The problem? Most buyers think they're the only ones who don't understand down payments, or feel anxious about making an offer, or wonder if they're being stupid for even considering buying right now.

You're not alone. These questions are normal. The anxiety is normal. The confusion is normal.

This guide answers the 20 most common questions honestly, the way I'd explain it to a friend, not the way a mortgage brochure would explain it.

---

Part 1: Money and Affordability

The questions that keep you up at night

1. Do I REALLY need 20% down, or is that just what everyone says?

Why everyone asks this: You've heard "20% down" your whole life. It sounds like the law. Your parents said it. Your friends say it. The internet says it.

The real answer: You can buy a house with as little as 3% down (conventional) or 3.5% down (FHA). VA and USDA loans? Zero down. The 20% myth persists because that's when you avoid PMI (private mortgage insurance), but PMI is usually $50-200/month. Annoying, but not the end of the world.

What gets misunderstood: "Just save 20% and you'll be fine!" Okay, but that takes 5-7 years for most people. Meanwhile, home prices are rising 3-5% annually in good markets and you're paying rent. Sometimes buying with 5% down today beats waiting 3 years to hit 20%.

Action step: Talk to a lender about your actual options. Run the numbers: 5% down with PMI vs. waiting 3 years to save 20%. Factor in rent paid and home appreciation during those 3 years. Sometimes good enough now beats perfect later.

2. How much house can I actually afford?

Why everyone asks this: Your lender says you qualify for $800K. Your parents say you should spend no more than $500K. Your friends are buying $700K houses. Who's right?

The real answer: Lenders use the 28/36 rule: no more than 28% of gross income on housing, 36% on total debt. But just because you QUALIFY for $800K doesn't mean you should SPEND $800K. Lenders don't know about your student loans, your car payment, or that you like to travel twice a year.

What gets misunderstood: "Never spend more than 3x your annual income!" This was good advice when interest rates were 3%. At 6-7% rates, the rules change. A $600K house at 3% costs $2,530/month. The same house at 6.5% costs $3,790/month. The ratio matters less than the actual monthly payment.

Action step: Calculate your actual monthly budget. Take your net (after-tax) monthly income. Subtract all your bills and expenses. Subtract $500 for home maintenance. What's left is your maximum comfortable housing payment. Work backwards from there to find your purchase price.

3. What are closing costs and why is everyone being vague about them?

Why everyone asks this: You've saved your down payment. You're ready. Then someone mentions closing costs. Several thousand dollars? On top of everything else?

The real answer: Closing costs are typically 2-5% of the purchase price and include:

• Loan origination fees (0.5-1% of loan)
• Appraisal ($500-800)
• Home inspection ($400-600)
• Title insurance and search
• Attorney fees ($1,500-3,000 in Connecticut)
• Prepaid property taxes and insurance
• Recording fees and transfer taxes

On a $500K house, expect $10-25K in closing costs. On an $800K house, $16-40K.

What gets misunderstood: "Just ask the seller to cover closing costs!" In a competitive market, this makes your offer weaker. In a buyer's market, sure. But when you're competing against cash buyers, don't handicap yourself.

Action step: Get a Loan Estimate from your lender within 3 days of applying. It breaks down every fee. Budget for the high end of the range so you're not scrambling.

4. What is PMI and is it really that bad?

Why everyone asks this: The internet makes PMI sound like the devil. Everyone says avoid it at all costs. But what IS it?

The real answer: Private Mortgage Insurance protects THE LENDER (not you) if you default. It's required on conventional loans with less than 20% down. Cost: usually 0.5-1% of the loan amount annually, divided into monthly payments. On a $400K loan, that's $2,000-4,000/year or $165-330/month.

Good news: PMI automatically cancels when you hit 78% loan-to-value (22% equity). You can request cancellation at 80% LTV (20% equity).

What gets misunderstood: "PMI is throwing money away!" Technically yes, it doesn't build equity. But neither does rent. If PMI of $200/month lets you buy 3 years sooner, and your home appreciates $30K in those 3 years, you came out ahead.

Action step: Don't avoid PMI just because the internet says it's bad. Do the math on your specific situation. Sometimes paying PMI for 3-5 years while building equity beats renting for 3-5 years while saving for 20%.

5. Can I buy a house if I have student loans, a car payment, or credit card debt?

Why everyone asks this: You're carrying $40K in student loans, a $400/month car payment, and maybe $3K on a credit card. Does that disqualify you?

The real answer: No, but it affects how much house you can afford. Lenders look at your Debt-to-Income ratio (DTI). They add up all your monthly debt payments plus your proposed mortgage payment, then divide by your gross monthly income.

Most lenders want DTI under 43%, some allow up to 50%.

Example: You make $80K/year ($6,667/month gross). Your debts: $300 student loan + $400 car + $100 credit card = $800/month. That's 12% DTI before the mortgage. You have 31-38% left for your housing payment, or about $2,000-2,500/month.

What gets misunderstood: "Pay off all debt before buying!" That sounds great, but if it takes you 3 years to pay off $30K in debt, you just spent 3 years renting instead of building equity. Sometimes it's smarter to buy with debt than wait.

Action step: Use a DTI calculator online. Enter your income and all debts. See how much housing payment you can afford. If you're close to the limit, consider paying down high-interest debt (credit cards) before buying.

---

Part 2: Getting Started

The "am I ready?" questions

6. How do I know if I'm actually ready to buy?

Why everyone asks this: Everyone has an opinion. Your parents say buy. Your coworker says wait. Your friends bought last year and seem happy.

The real answer: You're ready when these three things align:

• Financial readiness: Stable income, 3-6 months emergency fund AFTER down payment and closing costs, credit score 620+
• Life readiness: Plan to stay in the area 3-5+ years, job security, no major life changes coming
• Mental readiness: Willing to handle repairs, okay with less liquidity, not panicking about market timing

What gets misunderstood: "Wait for the market to crash!" People have been saying this since 2012. If you're financially ready and plan to stay 5+ years, trying to time the market is a fool's errand. Buy when you're ready, not when the market is "perfect."

Action step: If you can answer yes to all three readiness factors above, you're ready. If interest rates drop later, you can refinance. If prices dip, you're still building equity instead of paying rent.

7. What credit score do I actually need?

Why everyone asks this: You've heard 740+, 700+, 620+, 580+. Which is it?

The real answer:

• Conventional: 620+ (but 740+ gets best rates)
• FHA: 580+ for 3.5% down, 500-579 for 10% down
• VA: No official minimum, but most lenders want 580+
• USDA: 640+ typically

Every 20 points matters for your interest rate. A 680 score might get 6.5%, while a 740 gets 6.0%. Over 30 years on a $400K loan, that 0.5% difference is about $50K.

Action step: Check your credit score (free at Credit Karma or your bank). If it's under 680, spend 3-6 months improving it: pay down credit cards, don't open new accounts, fix any errors. If it's 680+, you're good to go.

8. What's the difference between pre-qualification and pre-approval?

Why everyone asks this: They sound the same. Your lender offers both. Which one matters?

The real answer:

Pre-qualification: A quick estimate based on what YOU tell the lender. No verification. Takes 10 minutes. Worth approximately nothing in a competitive market.

Pre-approval: Lender actually verifies your income, assets, credit, and debts. Issues a letter committing to lend you a specific amount. Takes a few days. This is what sellers want to see.

Action step: Skip pre-qualification entirely. Go straight to pre-approval. You'll need: 2 years of tax returns, 2 months of bank statements, recent pay stubs, and authorization to pull credit. Takes 2-3 days. Do this BEFORE you tour houses.

9. How long does this whole process actually take?

Why everyone asks this: Your lease is up in 4 months. Can you buy a house by then?

The real answer:

• Get pre-approved: 3-7 days
• House hunting: 2 weeks to 6 months (varies wildly)
• Offer to accepted contract: 1-7 days
• Under contract to closing: 30-45 days
• Total: 6 weeks to 8 months

The wild card is finding the right house. Some people find it on day 3. Others take 6 months.

Action step: If your lease is up in 4 months, start NOW. Get pre-approved this week. Start touring in 2 weeks. Assume 2 months to find the right house, 45 days to close. That puts you right at your deadline.

10. Do I really need a real estate agent, or can I just find houses online?

Why everyone asks this: You can see all the listings on Zillow. Why do you need an agent?

The real answer: Yes, you CAN buy without an agent. No, you SHOULDN'T. Here's what a good buyer's agent does:

• Access to off-market and coming-soon listings
• Negotiation expertise (this alone saves you thousands)
• Market knowledge about what properties actually sell for
• Coordination of inspections, appraisals, attorneys, lenders
• Red flag identification during tours
• Contract review and protection

And the buyer's agent commission is typically paid by the seller. You get representation for free.

What gets misunderstood: "Just contact the listing agent directly and save money!" The listing agent works for the SELLER, not you. Going directly to them gives you zero negotiating power and no protection.

Action step: Find a buyer's agent who specializes in your target area and price range. Interview 2-3 agents. Ask: How many first-time buyers have you worked with this year? What's your average days-to-close? Can you share references?

---

Part 3: The Loan Maze

Making sense of mortgage options

11. What type of mortgage should I get?

Why everyone asks this: FHA, conventional, fixed, ARM, 15-year, 30-year. It's alphabet soup and everyone has an opinion.

The real answer:

Conventional (most common): 620+ credit, 3-20% down. PMI required under 20% but cancels at 78% LTV. Best for stable income and decent credit.

FHA (lower credit/down payment): 580+ credit, 3.5% down. Mortgage insurance for life of the loan unless you refinance. Best for lower credit scores and minimal down payment.

VA (veterans/military): Zero down, no PMI. Best for eligible veterans and active duty.

USDA (rural properties): Zero down, income limits. Best for eligible rural/suburban properties.

Action step: Talk to your lender about which loan type fits your situation. Most first-time buyers end up with either conventional (5-20% down, 620+ credit) or FHA (3.5% down, 580+ credit).

12. Should I get a 15-year or 30-year mortgage?

Why everyone asks this: Your dad says 15-year. Your friend says 30-year. Who's right?

The real answer:

• 15-year: Lower rate (typically 0.5-0.75% lower), way less total interest, but payment is 50-60% higher
• 30-year: Higher rate, more total interest, but much lower monthly payment and more flexibility

Example: $400K loan at 5.5% (15-year) = $3,268/month vs. 6% (30-year) = $2,398/month. That's $870/month difference.

What gets misunderstood: "Always get 30-year and invest the difference!" In theory, yes. In practice, most people don't invest that extra $870/month. They spend it. If you're disciplined enough to invest the difference, the 30-year plus investing wins. If not, the 15-year forces wealth building.

Action step: Get quotes for both. If the 15-year payment fits comfortably, consider it. If it's tight, go 30-year and make extra payments when you can. Most first-time buyers choose 30-year for flexibility.

13. Can I buy a house with less than perfect credit?

Why everyone asks this: You made some mistakes in your 20s. Your credit is 640. Are you shut out?

The real answer: Absolutely not. FHA loans accept 580+ credit scores. Some lenders work with 500-579 if you put 10% down. Conventional starts at 620.

The trade-off: lower credit = higher interest rate. A 640 score might get 6.5% while a 740 gets 6.0%. On a $400K loan, that's about $125/month or $45K over 30 years.

Action step: If your score is 580-680, talk to an FHA lender. Ask about rate improvement programs. Many lenders offer streamline refinances after 12 months of on-time payments. You can buy now and improve your rate later.

14. Fixed rate or ARM?

Why everyone asks this: ARMs have lower initial rates. But they're scary. What if rates spike?

The real answer: A 7/1 ARM is fixed for 7 years, then adjusts annually. A 5/1 ARM is fixed for 5 years. The initial rate is typically 0.5-0.75% lower than a 30-year fixed.

ARMs make sense if you're confident you'll sell or refinance within the fixed period. Buying a starter home you'll outgrow in 5-7 years? An ARM could save you real money.

The risk: if you're still in the home when it adjusts and rates have spiked, your payment could jump $300-500/month.

Action step: Buying a forever home? Get a fixed rate. Buying a starter you'll move out of in 5-7 years? Consider a 7/1 ARM. Run the numbers on how much you save during the fixed period.

15. What are first-time buyer programs and how do I get them?

Why everyone asks this: Everyone says there are programs. But where? And what are they?

The real answer: First-time buyer programs vary by state and locality. Common benefits include:

• Down payment assistance grants ($5-15K)
• Lower interest rates
• Reduced closing costs
• Mortgage credit certificates (tax credits)
• Education and counseling programs

In Connecticut, look into CHFA (Connecticut Housing Finance Authority) programs. Most have income limits and require you haven't owned a home in the past 3 years.

What gets misunderstood: "First-time buyer programs are free money!" Sometimes. But many come with strings: higher interest rates, mandatory counseling, repayment if you sell within a certain number of years, or geographic restrictions.

Action step: Search for your state's first-time homebuyer programs. In Connecticut, start with CHFA.org. Talk to your lender about which programs they work with.

---

Part 4: The House Hunt

Finding the actual house

16. What should I actually look for when touring houses?

Why everyone asks this: You walk through and it looks fine. Pretty, even. But you don't know what you're missing.

The real answer: Red flags to watch for:

• Water damage: Stains on ceilings, musty smell, warped floors
• Foundation issues: Cracks wider than 1/4 inch, sloping floors, doors that don't close
• Electrical problems: Old fuse boxes, not enough outlets, flickering lights
• Age of major systems: Roof, HVAC, and water heater each have a 15-25 year lifespan
• Fresh paint everywhere: Could be hiding water damage or mold
• Weird layouts: Bedrooms only accessible through other bedrooms, bathrooms in strange locations

What gets misunderstood: "Bring a level, moisture meter, and outlet tester!" That's what your HOME INSPECTOR is for. During tours, use your eyes and nose. Notice obvious issues. Let the inspector find hidden problems after your offer is accepted.

Action step: Create a tour checklist. Turn on faucets (water pressure?), flush toilets, open all windows, check all doors, look in the attic and basement if possible, take photos and notes. Ask about the age of the roof, HVAC, and water heater.

17. How do I know if I'm overpaying?

Why everyone asks this: The house is listed at $650K. Should you offer $650K? $625K? $675K?

The real answer: Your agent should provide comparable sales (comps): similar houses that sold recently in the same area. Look for homes with similar:

• Square footage (within 10-15%)
• Bedrooms and bathrooms
• Lot size and condition
• Sold in the last 3-6 months
• Within 0.5-1 mile radius

If similar homes sold for $625-650K, then $650K asking is reasonable. If they sold for $600-625K, the asking price is high.

What gets misunderstood: "Use Zillow's Zestimate!" Zestimates are algorithms with 5-15% margins of error. They're a starting point, not gospel. Trust recent comparable sales over an algorithm.

Action step: Before making an offer, ask your agent for a detailed comp analysis. If the comps support the asking price and you love the house, offer asking or slightly above.

18. Should I buy a fixer-upper to save money?

Why everyone asks this: The nice houses are $700K. The fixer-uppers are $550K. You could save $150K, right?

The real answer: Maybe. Depends on what needs fixing, your skills, your cash reserves, and your timeline.

General cost guide:

• Cosmetic updates (paint, flooring, kitchens, bathrooms): $30-75K
• Major systems (roof, HVAC, electrical, plumbing): $20-50K each

What gets misunderstood: "Buy the worst house on the best street!" Sure, if you have $100K in cash and 12 months to renovate. For first-time buyers, this usually becomes a nightmare. Buy something that needs paint and new appliances, not a new roof and foundation.

Action step: If considering a fixer-upper, get a pre-inspection before making an offer. Have a contractor walk through and provide rough estimates. Add 30% to those estimates. If the math still works, proceed carefully.

19. What questions should I ask about the neighborhood?

Why everyone asks this: The house is great, but you don't know the area.

The real answer: Questions to ask and research:

• What's the school district like? (Even without kids, this affects resale value)
• What's the commute during rush hour? (Drive it yourself, don't trust Google Maps)
• Is there an HOA? What are the fees and rules?
• What's the noise level? (Traffic, trains, airport)
• Are there any planned developments nearby?
• What's the crime rate? (Check local police statistics)
• How are the neighbors? (Knock on doors and introduce yourself)

Action step: Visit the neighborhood at least 3 times: weekday morning, weekday evening, and weekend. Drive around. Walk around. Talk to people walking their dogs. Check local Facebook groups or Nextdoor to see what people actually talk about.

---

Part 5: Making the Offer

The scary part

20. How do I make a competitive offer without overpaying?

Why everyone asks this: You found THE house. You want it. But there are other buyers.

The real answer: A competitive offer has four components:

Price: If comps support asking price and there's competition, offer 3-5% over asking. Don't try to win by $1,000. Offer enough to clearly separate yourself from other buyers.

Contingencies: Keep the inspection contingency (you need this). Consider shortening the financing contingency from 45 to 21 days. Consider appraisal gap coverage (you'll pay up to a set amount over appraised value).

Earnest money: Standard is 1-2%. Offer 3-5% to show you're serious. You get this back at closing, and if financing falls through, you get it back. It's not additional money, just a show of commitment.

Flexibility: Offer to close on the seller's preferred timeline. Offer rent-back if they need to stay after closing. Waive minor repair requests under $500.

Action step: Before touring, decide your absolute maximum price. When you find the right house, don't nickel-and-dime. Offer your max (or close to it) with strong terms. It's better to overpay by $10K and get the house than underpay by $10K and lose it, then overpay by $30K on the next one out of frustration.

---

Final Thoughts

If you've read this far, you're more prepared than 90% of first-time buyers.

The questions you're asking are normal. The anxiety you're feeling is normal. The confusion about terminology is normal. Every homeowner you know felt exactly the same way when they bought their first house. They figured it out. You will too.

Here's the truth: there's no perfect time to buy. There's no perfect house. There's no perfect strategy. There's only:

• Are you financially ready?
• Does the house meet your needs?
• Can you afford the payment comfortably?

If yes to all three, buy the house. Stop overthinking. Stop waiting for perfect.

In 5 years, you won't remember if you paid $685K or $705K. You'll remember that you own a home, you're building equity, and you stopped paying rent.

Good luck. You've got this.

Christian Jeffrey | Sotheby's International Realty | Greenwich, Connecticut

---

Have questions about buying in Greenwich or Fairfield County? We're happy to help.

Martha Z Jeffrey | Sotheby's International Realty | (203) 964-7800 | marthazjeffrey.com